I followed a disjointed
research trail looking at a slide show created by students looking at
connectivism. (Layne, Dohm, & Pacey, 2014)
It
struck me how informal the connectivism theory of learning was and when
discussing the term "google it" with my stepson I became concerned
about the informal nature of this theory or so I thought. How often when we
were talking did we just "google it" when we didn't know a
term. My concern led me to look at the nature of what is called Plato's
Problem by Naom Chomsky.
"It is the gap
between knowledge and experience."
(I have since come
to a different understanding of knowledge but at this point I was thinking of
knowledge as just the cognitive understanding of something.)
My
stepson, Erick, then said something profound, “the
ability to problem solve using information, is more important than the
information you obtained.”
I looked at the TedEx Talk of George Siemens, one of the
founders of connectivism, speaking on the education and the need for networking
in education. (2010) Mr
Siemens talks about a course that he co-instructed with the co-founder of
connectivism, Stephen Downes. This course had no technological boundaries. The
students were encouraged to find their information outside of the technology of
the school, i.e. Moodle or Blackboard or instructor constrained
technology. the students to have no boundaries in their ability to discover
information. "They wanted the students to have information overload."
(Siemens, 2010)
This
randomness of information discovery went against my understanding of education,
especially nursing education. When nursing students graduate they must be able
to meet the competencies set out by the professional association, and pass the
NCLEX exam.
I
struggled with the usefulness of MOOC's, etc. because there was no opportunity
to problem solve or use the information that was obtained. Unless you have
experience with the knowledge -i.e.
execution of the knowledge is where online learning falls short - MOOC’s, edX,
and Coursera
Practice in execution firstly
1.
But as I see in nursing we use reflective
journals are used but can still be “fudged”
2.
Blogs/online discussion groups are used in this
course to deal – to evaluate the practice, execution
Then
evaluation of that execution
1.
Yet summative evaluation still would be needed in
a face-to-face manner for many social professions.
2.
Evaluation of the “character of the learner and
their execution” especially when dealing with the life altering practices of
health sciences knowledge remains important.
It
was this information and concerns that I brought with me to the meeting with my
roles and trends partner Magi Scallion.
References
Plato’s
Problem (updated 2014, October 29) Wikipedia. Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plato%27s_Problem on March 19th, 2015
Siemens,
George (2010, March 6) TEDxNYED - George Siemens https://youtu.be/4BH-uLO6ovI Retrieved March 17, 2015
Layne,
S., Dohm, A., & Pacey, R. (2014, Feb 20) Connectivism https://youtu.be/Bjrnjc_WTfU Retrieved March 19, 2015
No comments:
Post a Comment